Other Mommy Review: Jessica Chastain's Horror Opens at Number One Despite Brutal Reviews
Other Mommy Review: Jessica Chastain's Horror Opens at Number One Despite Brutal Reviews
There is a peculiar kind of success story playing out at the box office this weekend, and its name is Other Mommy. Universal Pictures' new horror film, directed by Rob Savage and starring Jessica Chastain in dual roles, opened on October 9, 2026 to an estimated 27.5 to 28 million dollars domestically, taking the number one spot — all while carrying some of the worst reviews and audience scores of any major release in years. It is a genuine paradox: a film that audiences apparently felt compelled to see, and then, by every measurable metric, did not enjoy.
Produced by James Wan's Atomic Monster alongside Blumhouse, and adapted from Josh Malerman's novel Incidents Around the House, Other Mommy had every ingredient of a prestige horror event. An Oscar-winning lead actress playing against herself. A director with a strong genre track record. A proven horror producer. A beloved source novel. And yet the result is a film that earned a D+ CinemaScore — the lowest audience grade handed to any film since Megalopolis in September 2024 — alongside a Rotten Tomatoes critics score hovering around 18 to 20 percent and an audience score of just 46 percent. This is our full review, and an honest look at one of the strangest box office stories of the year.
The Premise and the Source Material
Other Mommy is adapted from Josh Malerman's novel Incidents Around the House, and the film's central hook is its casting: Jessica Chastain plays dual roles as the mother Ursula and the sinister entity known as "Other Mommy". That duality is the engine of the entire film — a domestic horror built around the uncanny image of a mother confronted by a dark reflection of herself.
She is supported by a strong ensemble: Jay Duplass, Dichen Lachman, Arian Moayed and Karen Allen round out the cast, giving the film a credible dramatic foundation. On paper, this is exactly the kind of casting that elevates horror above its genre trappings, and Chastain's willingness to take on both roles — the protector and the threat — is the film's boldest creative choice. The question the film has to answer is whether that duality produces genuine terror or simply a gimmick stretched across a feature runtime.
Jessica Chastain's Dual Performance
Whatever else can be said about Other Mommy, Jessica Chastain's commitment is not in question. Playing dual roles is one of the most demanding challenges an actor can take on: it requires building two distinct physical and emotional vocabularies, often performing against nothing, and trusting that the effect will land in the edit. Chastain throws herself into both Ursula, the mother, and the entity that shadows her, and the technical craft of the dual performance is frequently the most watchable thing on screen.
The problem is that craft alone cannot carry a horror film. Dual performances live or die on the material surrounding them — the script has to give both halves of the performance somewhere meaningful to go. When the surrounding film works, a dual role becomes iconic. When it does not, even the finest acting can feel like virtuosity in service of diminishing returns. Other Mommy, by most accounts, falls into the latter category.
Where the Film Stumbles
The numbers tell a stark story. A critics score of around 18 to 20 percent on Rotten Tomatoes places Other Mommy among the worst-reviewed wide releases of the year. The audience score of 46 percent is little better — this is not a case of critics and audiences disagreeing, the classic "critic-proof" horror scenario. Both camps rejected it. And then there is the D+ CinemaScore, the grade given by opening-night audiences, which is the single most damning data point of all. It is the lowest audience grade for any film since Megalopolis in September 2024, and CinemaScore history suggests that films graded this poorly tend to collapse in their second weekend.
It is worth being fair about what these numbers actually measure. A D+ does not mean the film is incompetent; it means the audience that showed up on opening night — the most enthusiastic, most predisposed-to-like-it segment of the potential audience — walked out disappointed. That is a verdict on expectations as much as execution. With James Wan producing, Blumhouse and Atomic Monster behind it, and Jessica Chastain headlining, expectations were legitimately high. The gap between the promise of the package and the experience of the film is where that D+ lives.
Rob Savage, the director, deserves a note of context here. He is a filmmaker with real genre credentials and a genuine understanding of how horror works. That makes the reception more surprising, not less — this was not a film handed to an indifferent hired gun. Sometimes the elements simply do not cohere, and a strong cast and capable director cannot rescue material that is not working at the script level.
The Box Office Picture: A Commercial Paradox
Here is where the story gets genuinely fascinating. For all its critical punishment, Other Mommy is a commercial success story — at least in its opening frame. Thursday previews brought in 3.6 million dollars. Friday, including those previews, reached 12.6 million. The opening weekend landed at around 27.5 to 28 million dollars, enough to take the number one domestic spot.
Now set that against the production budget: 19 million dollars. A 27.5 to 28 million dollar domestic opening on a 19 million dollar budget means the film is nearly profitable after a single weekend, before international grosses and home entertainment are even counted. In the cold arithmetic of studio filmmaking, Other Mommy is already a win. Blumhouse practically invented this model — modest budgets, big swings, opening weekends that cover costs before word of mouth can do damage — and it has worked again.
This is the paradox that makes the film worth discussing beyond its quality. The same weekend that delivered a D+ CinemaScore and an 18 to 20 percent critics score also delivered the number one box office position and near-instant profitability. Audiences voted with their wallets to show up, and then voted with their grades to say they wished they had not.
The Bigger Picture for Horror in 2026
Other Mommy's opening also says something about the state of horror as a theatrical genre. The audience showed up. A 27.5 to 28 million dollar opening for an original horror film — not a sequel, not a franchise entry — proves that the appetite for theatrical horror remains strong. People still want to be scared in a room full of strangers. What they will not tolerate is feeling that the film did not respect their time, and the D+ suggests exactly that sentiment.
For Blumhouse and Atomic Monster, the lesson is double-edged. The low-budget model means a film can survive terrible reception, but surviving is not thriving. A second-weekend collapse — which the CinemaScore history strongly suggests is coming — would still leave the film profitable, yet it would also leave a mark on the brand. Audiences remember being burned. The next original horror film from these producers will have to work harder to earn back the trust that Other Mommy spent.
Verdict
Other Mommy is a film at war with itself: a committed dual performance from Jessica Chastain and a capable director in Rob Savage, stranded in a film that neither critics nor audiences could embrace. The verified numbers are brutal — around 18 to 20 percent from critics, 46 percent from audiences, and a D+ CinemaScore, the worst audience grade in two years. And yet it opened at number one with 27.5 to 28 million dollars on a 19 million dollar budget, making it a commercial success by the only metric studios ultimately answer to.
How to score a film like this? As a piece of cinema, it falls short of its considerable promise, and the audience grades justify a harsh assessment. We give Other Mommy 4 out of 10. The points it earns come from Chastain's evident commitment to the dual role and the professionalism of the production around her. Everything else — the scares, the story, the payoff — fails to land, and the D+ CinemaScore confirms that opening-night audiences agreed.
Should you see it? If you are a Jessica Chastain completist or a student of horror's commercial machinery, there is genuine interest here — both as a performance piece and as a case study in how a film can win the weekend and lose the audience in the same breath. But if you are looking for the next great horror film of 2026, keep looking. Other Mommy is a number-one hit that almost nobody liked, and that contradiction is ultimately more memorable than the film itself.
Follow The-NEXTGEN everywhere:
Facebook: The-NEXTGEN
Instagram: https://instagram.com/the_nextgenofficial
Threads: https://www.threads.com/@the_nextgenofficial
YouTube (BM-Bromania): https://youtube.com/@bmbromania
YouTube (The-NEXTGEN): https://youtube.com/@thenextgenyt
X (Twitter): https://x.com/thenextgengame
Telegram: https://t.me/thenextgenofficial
⚖️ Credits, DMCA & Fair Use Notice
- Visual Media: Sourced from respective global news agencies or generated via AI.
- Authorship: The textual content is uniquely drafted by PixelRadar AI Analytics.
Fair Use Policy: This article contains uniquely generated analysis for educational and news reporting purposes under the Fair Use doctrine. No copyright infringement is intended. If you are the rightful owner of any visual material and wish for it to be removed, please contact us. We will honor take-down requests within 24-48 hours.


